I'm sorry to say this but all of my 7 dogs, all of them hated it. You know reading the positive and negative reviews, I just thought that maybe as the human body is different so maybe the dogs also react to it differently. But damn, all the negative reviews were actually what I saw. My dogs just either were staring at the biscuits, spit it out or ate and vomited it out. Please, I request you buyers. It is the decision of the health of your dogs. Please don't take a gamble, just cuz it is cheap. Stick to Pedigree or Home made cooked food or even Parle-G is much much *200 times better than this crap.