The product is much better than the spring based holders. The tightening and gripping is managed by screws and so there is more confidence in the way the phone is held by the holder. Drawback - I have a MotoG with all power and vol control buttons on one side. So while tightening, the buttons get pressed. No problem with my Oneplus 6 (buttons on placed on either side). So thats a issue with Moto design ot this holder. Also felt price is a bit high for some plastic and a few screws.