To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Black Brother, Black Brother is a well written book that speaks about systemic racism. It gives voice to teens who experience disenfranchisement and empowers them to find ways to overcome this very real struggle. The book can also encourage others who are outside looking in, to look inwards to question the role they play to perpetuate this problem. I highly recommend this book to everyone especially to teachers to include in their social justice curriculum.
4.0 out of 5 starsPowerful indictment of racism and privilege for children aged 9+
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 13 September 2021
Donte Ellison spent most of his childhood in New York with his older brother Trey, his mum (a civil rights lawyer at the Legal Aid Society) and dad (a computer architect). When his mum got a job in Boston, the whole family moved to a suburb outside the city and Donte and Trey started school at Middlefield Prep. That’s where Donte’s problems started. Although his brother, Trey, is hugely popular and plays on the school basketball team, Donte doesn’t have any friends, isn’t good at sports (preferring computer games and reading his dad’s old SF novels) and from day one was bullied by Alan Davies, the captain of the school’s champion fencing team.
Alan is not subtle about why he’s targeting Donte: Donte is one of the few black students in what is a school populated by white, wealthy and very privileged students and so stands out. More than that though, is the fact that while Donte is dark skinned, Trey passes for white. Alan likes to shout “Black brother, black brother” at Donte as a way of drawing attention to his race and how different he is to Trey. Worse, the school turns a blind eye to the bullying, choosing to blame Donte for the cruel tricks played on him and around him and resulting in the teachers regarding him as a troublemaker.
Everything comes to a head when Donte is mistakenly blamed after Alan throws a pencil at a student. Sent once again to the Principal’s office this time, under the weight of the unfair accusations and micro aggressions (including comparisons to the light skinned Trey), Donte snaps and throws his back back into a chair. The next thing he knows, the Principal has phoned the police and Donte is being put in a police car on a charge of delinquency - all to Alan’s delight.
As Donte’s mother decides to file a civil law suit against the school, Donte tries to work out how to get back at Alan, how to make him see him as a human and not just as someone who is black. When Trey finds an article about Arden Jones, a black man who fenced for the USA in the 1976 Olympics, he realises that he can literally take on Alan at his own game. Jones now works as a manager for a boys and girls club in Boston and so Donte tracks him down, to try and persuade him to teach him how to fence but doing so starts him on a journey that teaches him so much more than how to fight and get revenge; it teaches him how to rise above and tackle a world that only sees his colour …
Jewell Parker Rhodes’s contemporary novel about racism for children aged 9+ is a blazing indictment of the unfairness of racism and the role that privilege and wealth play in producing unequal outcomes for black children compared with white children. The plot has shades of THE KARATE KID, the scene cuts are a little jumpy and Trey and Donte’s relationship needed more tension but this is a strong and sadly necessary read that is worth your time.
I picked this up having been impressed by Rhodes’s previous children’s novel GHOST BOYS, which also looked at racism in terms of police violence against black youths and the murder of Emmett Till. Here Rhodes’s focus is on the schools-to-prison pipeline and how educational establishments (aided by the police) disproportionately target black students as being disruptive or delinquents. Certainly as a Brit, it is horrifying to learn that a moment of bad behaviour in a school can lead a child to being arrested and taken away in handcuffs and labelled a delinquent with a juvenile criminal record. Rhodes then goes further to cleverly set out how Donte’s own privilege - as the child of wealthy parents who have brought him up to speak properly and respectfully and dress smartly - is of some assistance to him, especially the fact that he has a white father, with whom the police and judiciary react more favourably than his black mother. It’s a damning indictment of modern American society, made more effective by the way that Rhodes successfully conveys Donte’s emotional reaction to it - the confusion and upset and fear and anger.
Also good is how Rhodes shows the relationship between Donte and Trey and how while Donte loves his brother, he also resents how Trey’s lighter skin also makes it easier for him to assimilate and be accepted by the other students. The scenes where he initially bristles at Trey’s decision to try out for fencing because that’s Donte’s thing rang true and I have to say that I would have liked a bit more of that grit in their relationship purely because at times it’s a little too idealised in terms of their support for each other. For example, Trey’s initial assumption that Donte must have done something wrong to be arrested could have been teased out more than it is and I would have been interested in a scene between Donte’s mum and dad about the fact that the police are more deferential to a 6’4” white man than they are to a black woman who’s actually a lawyer. (That said, I should stress that I completely respect the choice not to focus on this because it is good to read a book about a supportive bi-racial family and it does mean the book focuses on Donte and his reactions to what’s happening).
The fencing element to the story reminded me a lot of THE KARATE KID, although I should say that Rhodes makes the story her own. I enjoyed the relationship between Donte and Arden Jones and how in learning how to fence Donte learns about himself and how to deal with the awful system he lives in. I think it’s a particularly clever decision of Rhodes to pick fencing as the central sport here because it does have an image as a white, European and privileged sport so to make clear how many people of colour have fenced for the USA in its Olympic team is a smart point to make and also because Rhodes shows how it can be democratised by bringing it to a poorer neighbourhood where black kids can be given the opportunity to learn.
Rhodes is an incredibly impressive writer when it comes to writing about racism and while I hate that books like this have to be written, she does a really good job at showing the emotional impact of it on Donte and how it makes him feel about himself. The clever decision she makes here to show how the wealth of Donte’s family can buy him a better outcome than poorer black children placed in the same position (and also how Donte is smart enough to realise this) brings home the intersectionality between privilege and race but also critically points out that just because a black child has a wealthy family doesn’t mean he’s going to be treated as fairly as a white child in the same situation.
Ultimately (and despite my criticisms) this is a powerful book that is well worth your time and is definitely worth a read.
This is a book that I think should be on every year 6 bookshelf! Black Brother, Black Brother is a powerful and compelling book about social injustice and inequality in a private prep school. And the characters are well placed to judge the racism that they face day after day as Donte is black and his older brother Trey is much lighter in skin tone. Their mother is black and their father white and it becomes obvious very early on that Donte sees the different ways his parents are treated in society-his mother may be a lawyer but her husband is the one that is deemed the one to talk to when Donte is arrested for something that he hasn’t done. The author is well placed to write about this inequality due to her own family situation and she does so in a very calm manner using Donte and his talent for fencing-which seen as a predominately white and upper class sport. I absolutely loved reading this to the 10 year old and it led to lots of discussion about race, justice and doing the right thing.
4.0 out of 5 starsA story about racial prejudice and bullying
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 2 August 2021
This was a well written book. It is aimed at the YA market so the writing reflects that.
Two brothers one black, one almost white with a white father and a black mother. Mother is a lawyer and the boys have recently moved to a new school which is a private one - mainly white middle-class children - many from very wealthy families.
The one brother is accepted and has no issues while poor Donte is not accepted or liked by pupils or staff. He is falsely accused of something in the classroom and is sent to the head teacher, while verbally defending himself Donte becomes in a worse situation and the police are called and he is arrested. He was not violent or aggressive in any way !!
He decides he is going to prove himself and begins to learn fencing from a former black Olympic fencer who was removed from the Olympic fencing team for some misdemeanor we learn about in the book.
It is a book that shows that good can triumph over evil and that the bullies don't always win!
5.0 out of 5 starsA great book with lear line of suggestions
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 August 2021
I loved every bit of it. Every bit but one - yet again, it seems like the field of discrimination is being privatised by people who are not Caucasian. This is wrong. It is being DIFFERENT that matters, being a 'newcomer', speaking a different language at home and standing out in a crowd. If this is acknowledged, the battle can be won. Otherwise, it is just politicising the whole concept of discrimination, making a huge community feel more vulnerable than so many other individuals who do not even have a community to seek protection from, and using it against many innocent people and not for all who need protection. There. Authors, listen! But I lived every bit of this book nonetheless. It is not a book of hatred and fight instigation. It is a book of rising and soaring, of finding one's strength within (and yet showing that a battle cannot be won when one is alone). A cozy book despite it challenging a huge issue. A good, easy read.
This story was captivating while educating the reader. It was a story about being black in a sea of white at school but it was also about shades of that blackness and Donte's desire to sometimes disappear from that visibility. Donte took a journey in this school through sport and the things learnt along the way for him and those around him completely had my attention. Such a stunning read for any teen.
5.0 out of 5 starsGreat tale that is both a satisfying story and a good exploration of racism for younger readers
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 25 July 2021
So often a book written for a cause (such as anti-racism) suffers because the story doesn't hold its own. So it is really satisfying to read this tale, which is both a great read in itself about a young man growing and maturing and an excellent exploration of racism for younger readers. Heartily recommended.
A very well written book, beautifully written in a calm and precise prose but with well crafted story line tugging you along. I read it together with my child and this book provides an eye opener for him. The lesson taught through the entertaining book is invaluable.
I ordered three books for my 12-year old son. I wanted to start the conversation about race and privilege but wasn’t sure how. We ordered three books and this was the first one. He loved it even though it was challenging, but he is beginning to acknowledge his perspective is vastly different, and that knowing that his friends and peers will experience circumstances differently than him is helping him understand what’s happening in our community. I highly recommend this book.